Are Plants Conscious?
J C Bose and the Nature of Explanation



Sir Jagadish Chandra Bose FRS
______________________

Born 30 Nov 1858
Died 23 Nov 1937

Founder of 




 

News November 2009
New biography is now available:

by D P Sen Gupta (Indian Institute of Science, India), M H Engineer (JC Bose Institute, India) & V A Shepherd (University of New South Wales, Australia)


The Indian scientist Sir Jagadish Chandra Bose was both physicist and plant physiologist.  In his early life he invented a new type of coherer - an early form of radio signal detector - which enabled him to transmit radio waves over distance a full year before Marconi.  He spent much of the rest of his life exploring minute responses to external stimuli applied to plants.  He demonstrated that plant tissues under different kinds of stimulation produce electric responses similar to those produced by animal tissues. His extraordinary experimental results were achieved by using a range of ultra sensitive measuring instruments - also his own invention. He was the first Indian scientist to be elected to The Royal Society - in London, 1920.

His plant sensitivity findings can be explained in a number of ways. Some scientists prefer to use conventional materialist explanations in terms of the flow and transmission of chemical and bio-chemical substances. And, as V.A. Shepherd has pointed out, Bose "had argued all along the importance of electrical signalling in plants, and the world has now come around to this view."   Others, mainly in the East, see Bose's findings as providing support for ancient Hindu vedantic theories of consciousness - even in plants. Bose himself was comfortable with both approaches to the explanation and understanding of his findings.  

This project uses J C  Bose's life and work as a inspirational base from which to explore these different kinds of explanation, and their implications.

Progress Notes: December 2009

We do recommend that you read the new approved biography of J C Bose prepared by D P Sen Gupta, M H Engineer and V A Shepherd, particularly its section by Gupta which corrects a number of earlier misconceptions and errors about Bose's life.  It is perhaps the nearest thing to an 'approved' biography since Patrick Geddes seminal work in 1920.

Following a suggestion made early last year by the Director of the Bose Institute I have put additional resources and effort into expanding the sections on Consciousness, in particular the new, sometimes weird and wonderful, ideas by quantum physicists.  These certainly provide a challenge to followers of Popper who insists on theories being intrinsically testable, (or more correctly: falsifiable), and provide some fun as well.
____________________________________________________

bose@areplantsconscious.com

If you have an interest in 
J C Bose, or in any of the topics involved in this project, 
then please send me an email. 
Many thanks for suggestions and ideas already received. 

_____________________________________


Book and interactive CD
completion date: some time in 2010

________________________



Neils Bohr's structure of the atom:
materialist wisdom



 


The Vedanta: spiritual wisdom

Reasoning and decision making application provided by:

Note taking software provided by

India travel, visits to Bose family and 
Bose Institute organised by:


JC Bose was also known as:
Jagish Chandra Basu
Jagadishchandra Basu


Not just a scientist.

 Bose  was also a member of the literary discussion circle led by his friend, Nobel Prize winning author, poet and thinker Rabrindranath Tagore - also from Calcutta. His first short story was:
     Polatok Tufan in Obbakto.


Basu or Bose

Basu: Indian (Bengal) and Bangladeshi: Hindu (Kayasth) name, from Bengali bošu (from Sanskrit vasu, which has many meanings including ‘wealth’, ‘gem’, ‘radiance’). It is an epithet of Shiva and of several other gods. 
Bose: an anglicised form of Basu.

Plant Neurobiology

Bose should also be called the father of the new discipline of 'plant neurology'. Recently formed, The Society of Plant Neurobiology is at: http://www.plantneurobiology.org/.
Their mission statement includes: " ...will serve the community of scientists interested in sensory plant biology, plant electrophysiology and communicative plant ecology...". The great scientist would have been thrilled.

Anthropomorphism?

Brilliant science can be found in the Journal of the Neurobiologists and proceedings of their conferences. But in naming the processes they observe and test, are they falling into the anthropomorphism trap?  And when they use concepts like 'discriminating between self and other" when describing the behaviour of plant roots under different conditions, or 'intelligence', or 'consciousness', are they using homology when in fact they should be using analogy - far less powerful a concept?  The danger is that although the scientists themselves know what they mean, outsiders extend that meaning in unwarranted ways. Just because one uses the same word to describe phenomena in people and in plants, it doesn't necessarily mean they are the same phenomena.  In the words of the song: it ain't necessarily so.


Brian Champness is a retired academic psychologist and researcher. He was  born under the Raj in what was then called Calcutta, on Lower Circular Road, now called Acharya JC Bose Road.  After six student years at Exeter University, followed by three as a Research Fellow at University College London, he taught full time at Plymouth University (formerly Polytechnic), occasionally at the University of Sussex, and joyfully at New York University, USA, as a Visiting Professor from '80 to'85. For the next 20 years he consulted and researched for a variety of public and private organisations, travelling frequently and widely across Europe,  the Far East and his beloved India. He has now postponed organising Chamber Music concerts in order to concentrate on the life and times of one of India's great scientists, and to look at how his work has been developed and explained.
 

Acharya Jagadish Chandra Bose with his students

Bose (centre) with students: front row:  Meghnad Saha, J.C. Ghosh, back row: S. Dutta, S.N. Bose, D.M. Bose, N.R. Sen, J.N. Mukherjee and N.C. Nag (see Frontline, Volume 21 - Issue 24, Nov. 20 - Dec 03, 2004)



150th Anniversary events

Wonderful new website celebrating J C Bose: www.jcbose.org


Bose Institute, as a part of year long programme to commemorate 150th birthday of its founder, held an International Symposium in Commemoration of the 150th Anniversary from 24-28th November 2009. www.boseinst.ernet.in

 

Christ's College, Cambridge University, held an event on Saturday 6th December, in memory of Sir J C Bose's 150th anniversary.
Nice summary report here:


Consciousness

"What is your substance, whereof are you made...?" 
Shakespeare Sonnet no. 53.

"That I exist is a perpetual surprise." 
Rabindranath Tagore.

"Vedanta divides the degrees of consciousness into five broad categories: acchadita (covered), sankucita (shrunken), mukulita (budding), vikasita (blooming) and purnavikasita (fully bloomed). Trees and plants, for example, are almost inert. They fall into the category of ‘covered consciousness.’ When we observe them carefully, we see that they have a limited or covered consciousness. The famous scientist Jagadish Chandra Bose reported that plants do have consciousness.”  T.D. Singh in 'Hindiusm and Science.' 

How does this approach to the understanding of consciousness compare with some of the ideas on 'levels of consciousness' in present day psychology, philosophy and neurology?

"In Hinduism there are two categories of knowledge – (i) para vidya - the
spiritual knowledge and (ii) apara vidya - material knowledge. Scientifc knowledge is the realm of apara vidya. Spiritual knowledge - knowledge of God and life - belongs to para vidya. Hinduism points out that scientific knowledge can lead to spiritual knowledge."  Singh ibid.

How far did Bose journey into the apara vidya realm in the way he discussed and thought about his work?
 


On the shoulders of giants...

"From Semi-Conductors to the Rhythms of Sensitive Plants: The Research of J.C. Bose", V.A. Shepherd (2005). Cellular and Molecular Biology 51, 607-619.
email: vas@phys.unsw.edu.au

'The Life and Work of
Sir Jagadis C. Bose
'
(1920), by Patrick Geddes

'Jagadis Chandra Bose and the Indian Response to Western Science' (1999) by Subrata Dasgupta